Sarai

Buying

WLTP, NEDC or CLTC: how far an electric car really goes in Pakistan

Why two electric cars with the same range on paper go different distances: the WLTP, NEDC and CLTC tests explained, and the range to plan around in Pakistan.

Every electric car is sold with a range figure, and in Pakistan those figures come from three different laboratory tests. A car rated 500 km on one test and a car rated 500 km on another do not go the same distance. This guide explains the three tests, shows how far apart they are, and gives the distance to plan around for the cars on sale here.

The three tests

NEDC is the New European Driving Cycle, the oldest of the three. Europe stopped using it for new cars in 2018. It accelerates gently, averages about 34 km/h and touches 120 km/h only briefly. Several Chinese makers still quote it for cars they export, including some sold in Pakistan.

WLTP is the test Europe uses now. It runs for 30 minutes over about 23 km, averages about 46 km/h, reaches 131 km/h and accelerates harder. It is the closest of the three to ordinary driving, and it is still a laboratory.

CLTC is China's own test, built from Chinese city traffic. It averages about 29 km/h, tops out at 114 km/h and spends a lot of time stopped. An electric car is at its most efficient at low speed, so this test produces the biggest numbers of the three.

Test Average speed Top speed The number it gives
WLTP about 46 km/h 131 km/h The most realistic of the three
NEDC about 34 km/h 120 km/h Generous
CLTC about 29 km/h 114 km/h The most generous

A fourth test, the American EPA figure, is stricter than all three. It is rarely quoted for cars sold in Pakistan.

Why none of them is your range

All three are run indoors at a mild temperature, with the air-conditioning off and nobody in the back seat. A Pakistani motorway in June is none of those things. Three differences matter most.

  • Speed. Air resistance rises with the square of speed. Cruising at 120 km/h costs far more energy per kilometre than the 30 to 46 km/h these tests average.
  • Heat. The air-conditioning runs from the same battery as the motor, and the car also spends energy keeping the battery itself cool.
  • Load. Five people and luggage are not what the test carried.

Around town the gap is smaller. At city speeds most electric cars get much closer to their rated figure.

How this site converts the brochure figure

Every range on Sarai is shown as a distance to plan around, not the brochure figure. It is worked out the same way for every car: the rated figure is scaled for the test it came from, and a tenth of the battery is kept in reserve so that you arrive with something left.

Brochure figure Scaled to Then a tenth in reserve Plan around
WLTP 76 percent yes 68 percent of rated
NEDC 65 percent yes 59 percent of rated
CLTC 61 percent yes 55 percent of rated
No test named 72 percent yes 65 percent of rated

These are planning figures for a motorway trip with the air-conditioning on. They are not a measurement of each car, and a careful driver at 100 km/h will often do better. They are set low on purpose, because running short between two chargers costs far more than arriving with spare range.

What 500 km on the brochure means

On the brochure Plan around
500 km WLTP about 342 km
500 km NEDC about 293 km
500 km CLTC about 274 km

That is a difference of about 68 km between two cars with the same number on the brochure. The range converter does this sum for any figure you type in.

The cars on sale, by test

Of the 71 fully electric cars on sale in Pakistan with a rated range, 31 quote WLTP, 8 quote NEDC and 13 quote CLTC. The other 19 are listed here with a range and no test named, which is common in local launch material.

These are the 12 that go furthest once every figure is put on the same footing:

Car Rated range Test Plan around Price
Audi A6 e-tron 756 km WLTP about 520 km PKR 2.885 crore to 3.385 crore
Mercedes-Benz EQE 660 km WLTP about 454 km PKR 5.46 crore
Mercedes-Benz EQS SUV 660 km WLTP about 454 km PKR 8.5 crore
Audi Q6 e-tron 625 km WLTP about 430 km PKR 4.82 crore
BMW i7 625 km WLTP about 430 km PKR 6.59 crore to 8.888 crore
Zeekr 7X 615 km WLTP about 423 km PKR 2.499 crore to 2.699 crore
Hyundai Ioniq 6 614 km WLTP about 422 km PKR 2.3 crore
Audi e-tron GT 598 km WLTP about 411 km PKR 5.7 crore
Mercedes-Benz EQE SUV 590 km WLTP about 406 km PKR 6.4 crore
Avatr 11 730 km CLTC about 401 km PKR 2.7 crore to 2.9 crore
BMW i5 582 km WLTP about 400 km PKR 2.5 crore to 3.296 crore
Zeekr 009 582 km WLTP about 400 km PKR 4.6 crore to 4.9 crore

Every car on sale is listed with its plan-around range on the electric cars page, and the car finder filters by it.

What else shortens range

  • Tyre pressure. Soft tyres cost range every kilometre. Check them before a long drive.
  • A roof rack or carrier. Anything on the roof adds drag at motorway speed.
  • Hills. A climb such as the road to Murree uses far more than level ground, and the descent gives only part of it back.
  • Battery age. Capacity falls slowly over the years, and the rated figure is for a new car.

How to use the figure

Compare cars on the plan-around number. It puts every car on the same footing, whichever test its maker chose. The comparison tool shows it side by side for up to three cars.

Check it against your route. A car is fine for a motorway if its plan-around range is comfortably longer than the longest gap between chargers. The route pages give the gaps on each motorway, stop by stop.

Do not buy range you will not use. For driving inside a city, every car in the table above covers several days on a charge. A bigger battery costs more and takes longer to fill.

Sources

Questions

Questions people ask

What is the difference between WLTP, NEDC and CLTC range?

They are three laboratory tests. WLTP is the current European test and the most realistic. NEDC is the older European test and is more generous. CLTC is China's test, runs at lower speeds, and gives the highest figures.

Which range figure is the most accurate?

Of the three, WLTP. Even so, plan on about 68 percent of a WLTP figure for a motorway trip in Pakistan with the air-conditioning on and a reserve kept back.

Why do some electric cars show such a high range?

Usually because the figure is CLTC or NEDC. Both tests run at low average speeds, where an electric car is most efficient. Plan on about 55 percent of a CLTC figure and about 59 percent of an NEDC figure.

How far can an electric car go on one charge in Pakistan?

The longest of the cars on sale is the Audi A6 e-tron, at about 520 km to plan around against a rated 756 km. The middle half of the cars on sale plan around 239 to 362 km.

Does air-conditioning reduce an electric car's range?

Yes. It draws from the same battery as the motor. The effect is largest in slow traffic on a hot day, when the car covers little distance for the energy the cooling uses.

Keep reading

More on EVs in Pakistan

All guides

Plan it in the app

Every charger on this page is on the map, with live status on the Sarai network and a planner that knows your car. Free on Android and iOS.

Download the app Join on WhatsApp